What to Say to an Insurance Adjuster After a Car Accident [2025 Guide]

What to Say to an Insurance Adjuster

After a car accident, you may get a call from an insurance adjuster within days, or even hours.

Whether they represent your insurance company or the other driver’s, their goal is the same: gather information that can help settle the claim quickly, and for as little money as possible.

That’s why it’s critical to approach these conversations carefully.

Saying the wrong thing, even unintentionally, can damage your ability to recover full compensation.

What You Should Say to an Insurance Adjuster

There are only a few key facts you should confirm when speaking with an insurance adjuster, and nothing more unless advised by a lawyer.

Facts include:

• Your name and basic contact information
• The time, date, and location of the accident
• The vehicles involved
• Whether police were called and if a report was filed
• Contact information for any witnesses (if applicable)

Stick to the facts.

If you’re unsure about something, say so.

Never guess or make assumptions.

Example:

“I was involved in a collision on April 10 at the intersection of Main and 5th Street around 3:15 p.m. The police responded, and I believe they filed a report.

I’m still gathering information and would prefer to have my attorney speak on my behalf moving forward.”

What You Should Not Say to an Insurance Adjuster

Here’s what to avoid saying during these conversations.

Some statements can be used to challenge your claim, reduce your compensation, or even shift blame.

1. Don’t Admit Fault, Even Partially

Even saying something like “I didn’t see them coming” or “I might’ve been going a little fast” can be twisted into an admission of fault.

In many states, admitting even partial fault can drastically reduce or eliminate your compensation.

2. Don’t Discuss Injuries in Detail

It’s common to say “I’m fine” or “I don’t think I’m hurt,” especially in the early days when adrenaline is high and injuries may not be fully apparent.

But this can hurt your case if you later discover a concussion, soft tissue damage, or internal injuries.

Only discuss injuries once a medical professional has evaluated you and never without legal guidance.

3. Don’t Speculate About the Accident

If you don’t know exactly what happened, say that.

Guessing about things like speed, road conditions, or what another driver was doing can lead to inconsistencies that work against you.

4. Never Agree to a Recorded Statement Without Legal Advice

Insurance adjusters often ask, “Do you mind if I record this call?” You should.

A recorded statement can be picked apart and used to dispute your version of events.

Politely decline and say your attorney will be handling further communication.

5. Don’t Discuss Settlement Offers

If the adjuster offers a quick settlement, don’t accept or even entertain it without legal counsel.

These early offers are often far below what your case is truly worth, especially if your medical treatment is ongoing.

Topics to Avoid Discussing With an Insurance Adjuster

There’s a clear list of topics you should not get into during any conversation with an insurance adjuster.

Topics to avoid include:

• Assigning or accepting blame for the car crash
• Describing how fast you were driving or what you were doing before the crash
• Offering medical opinions or saying how you “feel” physically
• Talking about whether you’ve returned to work
• Sharing social media posts or photos from the accident
• Naming other potentially responsible parties without a full legal understanding
• Discussing your legal strategy or whether you plan to hire a lawyer

Common Tactics Insurance Adjusters Use

Insurance adjusters are trained to gain your trust and lower your guard.

They may seem polite and friendly, but their job is to save the company money.

Tactics to watch out for includes:

• “Just want to clear up a few details…”
• “We just need a quick recorded statement for the file.”
• “We’re trying to get this resolved quickly for you.”
• “You don’t need a lawyer for this.”
• Any friendly small talk to get you to relax

1. “Just want to clear up a few details…”

This sounds casual, but it’s a way to get you to talk more than you should.

Any informal “clarifications” can later be used to weaken your claim.

2. “We just need a quick recorded statement for the file.”

This is rarely in your best interest.

Recorded statements can be replayed, dissected, and used against you, especially if your injuries or understanding of the accident evolve over time.

3. “We’re trying to get this resolved quickly for you.”

This is code for “We want to pay as little as possible before you realize what your case is really worth.”

If you’re still receiving treatment or don’t know the full extent of your injuries, a quick settlement may leave you without recourse for future expenses.

4. “You don’t need a lawyer for this.”

If an insurance adjuster says this, it’s a red flag.

They may be hoping to settle with you before you understand your rights or what your claim is truly worth.

5. Any friendly small talk to get you to relax

Adjusters may ask how your day is going or chat about unrelated topics to make the conversation seem casual.

Don’t be fooled.

They’re listening closely for anything they can use to challenge your claim.

Final Tip: Don’t Handle the Insurance Company Alone

The most important thing you can say to an insurance adjuster is: “I’d prefer you speak with my attorney.”

This simple phrase sets a boundary and ensures that every communication is handled professionally and strategically.

At TorHoerman Law, we deal with insurers every day, and we know how to protect our clients from being misled, pressured, or shortchanged.

Why Hiring a Personal Injury Lawyer Is Important

After a car accident, dealing with injuries, vehicle damage, and mounting medical bills is already overwhelming.

Adding phone calls from insurance adjusters, whose interests often conflict with your own, can push things from stressful to unmanageable.

That’s where hiring a personal injury lawyer becomes not only helpful but essential.

When you’ve been injured due to someone else’s negligence, your focus should be on recovering, not learning how to navigate insurance company tactics.

An experienced attorney will handle those conversations for you, protect your legal rights, and work to secure the full compensation you deserve.

Insurance Companies Are Not on Your Side

Despite their friendly tone, insurance adjusters work for large corporations with one mission: to protect their bottom line.

They are trained to find ways to reduce, delay, or deny payouts, often by exploiting gaps in your statement or offering quick, low-value settlements before the full cost of your injuries is known.

Many injured victims don’t realize that even their own insurance company may not act in their best interest once a claim is filed, possibly even leveraging loopholes in your insurance policy that result in lower payouts.

Without legal representation, you might also unintentionally say or agree to something that limits your ability to recover fair compensation.

A personal injury lawyer serves as a buffer between injury victims and the insurance company.

The professionals manage all communication, respond strategically, and ensure that nothing said or submitted can be used to weaken your case.

Legal Representation Levels the Playing Field

Insurance companies employ teams of adjusters, investigators, and lawyers whose job is to minimize their liability.

As an injured individual, you’re at a disadvantage if you try to go it alone.

Hiring a personal injury attorney instantly levels the playing field.

Your lawyer understands the tactics insurers use and how to push back.

They know how to collect and present evidence, such as medical records, accident reports, and witness testimony, in a way that supports your claim.

More importantly, they know how to calculate the full value of your case, including the following damages.

Damages that lawyers calculate include:

• Medical expenses (past, current, and future)
• Lost wages and reduced earning capacity
• Pain and suffering
• Emotional distress
• Property damage

Without legal guidance, it’s easy to underestimate the total cost of your accident and accept a settlement that doesn’t begin to cover it.

An Attorney Can Help Maximize Your Settlement

One of the key benefits of hiring a lawyer is the potential to recover significantly more compensation than if you handled the claim on your own.

Studies have shown that accident victims who work with attorneys generally receive larger settlements, even after legal fees are taken into account.

How a lawyer helps maximize your claim with the following strategies includes:

• Thorough case evaluation: Your attorney will assess the full scope of your losses, including long-term health complications and the emotional toll of your injuries.
• Evidence collection and preservation: Lawyers work quickly to secure witness statements, surveillance footage, and accident reconstruction reports before they are lost or altered.
• Expert consultations: They may bring in medical professionals, economists, or accident reconstruction experts to strengthen your claim.
• Lien negotiation: If health insurers or providers have placed liens on your settlement, your lawyer can negotiate reductions, ensuring you take home more of the compensation you’re awarded.
• Strategic timing: An experienced attorney knows when to wait, when to negotiate, and when to push for trial to ensure your case is resolved at the right moment.

Protecting You From Legal Pitfalls

The personal injury process can involve complex legal issues, including comparative fault, subrogation, and statute of limitations concerns.

Even a minor misstep can jeopardize your entire claim.

A skilled attorney knows how to avoid these pitfalls with the following steps:

• Filing your claim within the applicable time limits
• Responding properly to insurer requests
• Ensuring your case isn’t dismissed on a technicality
• Avoiding statements or actions that can be misinterpreted as admissions of fault

They also understand how local laws (such as modified comparative negligence or state-specific auto insurance requirements) can affect your case, and they apply that knowledge to build the strongest claim possible.

You Pay Nothing Unless You Win

Most reputable personal injury law firms — including TorHoerman Law — work on a contingency fee basis.

This means you pay nothing upfront, and the attorney only gets paid if they recover compensation on your behalf.

That arrangement makes high-quality legal representation accessible to everyone, regardless of financial circumstances.

There’s no risk in reaching out for legal guidance, but there can be serious consequences if you try to navigate the claims process alone.

How TorHoerman Law Supports Clients After a Car Accident

At TorHoerman Law, we’ve spent years helping injured individuals take on powerful insurance companies and recover the compensation they need to heal and move forward.

When you work with us, you can expect:

• Direct communication: We take the time to explain your rights, answer your questions, and keep you informed throughout your case.
• Medical coordination: We help connect you with the care you need and track treatment progress to document your injuries effectively.
• Comprehensive case building: Our team gathers the evidence, interviews witnesses, consults experts, and builds a claim that’s ready for negotiation or trial, if necessary. Plus, we make sure that you file your case within the state’s statute of limitations.
• Insurance negotiations: We handle all interactions with the insurance company, ensuring your words aren’t misused and that your best interests are protected.

Our goal is to take the legal burden off your shoulders so you can focus on what matters most: your recovery.

Wrapping Up: Do's and Don'ts When Talking to Insurance Adjusters

What you say to an insurance adjuster after a car accident can directly impact your ability to recover fair compensation, especially if the accident wasn’t your fault.

Adjusters are trained to ask questions that seem harmless but are designed to limit liability and reduce payouts.

Even a brief conversation can result in statements being taken out of context, potentially damaging your case.

That’s why it’s critical to proceed with caution and consider legal representation early in the process.

A personal injury lawyer from TorHoerman Law can handle all communication with the insurance company on your behalf, protecting your rights while you focus on healing.

If you’ve been injured in a car accident, don’t face the insurance company alone.

Contact TorHoerman Law for a free consultation.

We’ll guide you through the process, fight for the compensation you deserve, and make sure your voice is heard when it matters most.

Your recovery starts with the right support.