A Pennsylvania court’s order outlining Philips’ responsibility to preserve evidence is preventing repairs and returns of devices to customers, the company says. The Philips continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) therapy machine for sleep apnea and other related sleep apnea devices have been linked to cancer diagnoses in users due to insulating foam potentially degrading and being ingested or chemical emissions in new machines being inhaled.
Plaintiff’s attorneys responded by saying that they are opposed to the company having the ability to dispose of components they are supposed to be repairing and replacing, citing that these components are “tangible things” that could be evidence in the multidistrict litigation.
Philips filed an emergency request asking the court to modify the pretrial order, saying that under US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) rules, the company must replace the foam in the machines and was failing to do that because of this pretrial order.
335,000 devices have been returned to Philips due to the recall. Around 115,000 devices have been repaired and sent back to customers. The court order halted repairs in progress, setting the company behind over 55,000 devices by the time the court meets next in December.
More than half of the plaintiff’s attorneys objected to the emergency request, and now the company has until Wednesday November 17th to articulate how the pretrial order would affect their ability to fix and replace the machines. Plaintiff’s attorneys also filed a brief arguing that Philips should preserve the defective foam it was removing from the recalled machines and should make copies of the devices memory cards to serve as evidence of the users’ exposure to the foam, forming an accurate reserve of evidence for the lawsuits.
The FDA recalled 20 different models of Philips Respironics Ventilators, BiPAP, and CPAP Machines in June 2021. The injuries resulting from the defective products include but are not limited to lung cancer, asthma, headache, nausea/vomiting, and hypersensitivity.
As devices have been recalled, former users have sometimes been left with no solutions to their sleep issues as they’ve relied on the machine for quite some time.
You may qualify for a lawsuit if your device was recalled and a lung cancer diagnosis can be linked to use of a Philips device. If you qualify for the Philips lung cancer case above and are seeking this kind of help, reach out to our team at TorHoerman Law to find someone right for you.
From the first time Eric spoke with me and my husband, we knew he would work for us, not against us. Eric, Kristie and the entire team have been amazing.
From the moment I met them, it felt like a weight lifted – TorHoerman Law was confident, ready to fight, and truly cared about me as a person.
Rear-ended on my way to work, I ended up a patient in my own ER – TorHoerman Law took over the insurance nightmare so I could focus on getting better.
After months of chiropractic bills from an accident that wasn’t my fault, TorHoerman Law got involved and made the whole process easy – they treat you like family, not a number.
After a hit-and-run left me with a shattered leg and no idea where to turn – TorHoerman Law took over everything, got me every dollar available, and made me feel like family.
I have had many speed bumps to get over on information needed to file my claim that has had me stressing out several times, but once I have gotten in touch with TorHoerman Law I always come out with most of my problems handled. Nikki has been very much helpful in aiding me with my complaint and never lets me go feeling like I’m clueless as to what to do next. She listens and responds very efficiently and with very positive attitude and that’s always helpful. Thanks TorHoerman Law for your advice and support I appreciate all y’all have done for me.